18:0481(63)AR - Army, HQ XVIII Airborne Corps and Fort Bragg and AFGE Local 1770 -- 1985 FLRAdec AR
[ v18 p481 ]
18:0481(63)AR
The decision of the Authority follows:
18 FLRA No. 63
DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY,
HEADQUARTERS XVIII AIRBORNE
CORPS AND FORT BRAGG
Activity
and
AMERICAN FEDERATION OF GOVERNMENT
EMPLOYEES, LOCAL 1770
Union
Case No. 0-AR-858
DECISION
This matter is before the Authority on exceptions to the award of
Arbitrator L. Lawrence Shultz filed by the Agency under section 7122(a)
of the Federal Service Labor-Management Relations Statute and part 2425
of the Authority's Rules and Regulations.
The grievance in this case concerns the claim of the grievant that
she performed the duties of a higher-grade position for an extended
period of time for which she was entitled under the parties' collective
bargaining agreement to have been temporarily promoted. The Arbitrator
sustained the grievance finding that the grievant was entitled under the
agreement to have been temporarily promoted for the period of June 8,
1983 to August 24, 1983. Accordingly, the Arbitrator awarded the
grievant backpay for that period in the amount of the difference in what
she was paid and what she should have been paid.
In its exceptions the Agency contends that the award is deficient
because the grievant did not meet the minimum qualification requirements
for a temporary promotion to the position in dispute. The Agency cites
the Authority's decision in Adjutant General, State of Michigan,
Department of Military Affairs and National Association of Government
Employees, 11 FLRA 13 (1983) and maintains that "it was established
during the arbitration hearing that the grievant was not fully
qualified."
As noted by the Agency, the Authority held in Adjutant General, State
of Michigan, that in order for an employee to be properly promoted
consistent with civil service law and regulation, the employee must meet
at the time of the promotion the minimum qualification requirements for
the position to which the employee is to be promoted. Accord Federal
Correctional Institution, Petersburg, Virginia and American Federation
of Government Employees, Appomattox Local 2052, 16 FLRA No. 86 (1984).
In Adjutant General, State of Michigan, the activity identified the
specific minimum qualification requirement that the activity had
determined that the grievant did not possess and the arbitrator
expressly agreed with the activity's determination. Similarly, in
Federal Correctional Institution, Petersburg, the activity again
specified the particular minimum qualification requirement that the
grievant did not meet and the Office of Personnel Management confirmed
that the grievant did not meet that minimum qualification requirement
for the position in dispute. In terms of this case, the Arbitrator
failed to address the grievant's qualification for promotion to the
position in dispute, and the Authority finds that the Agency has not
specifically established that the grievant did not meet minimum
qualification requirements. Thus, whether the grievant met minimum
qualification requirements for the promotion is uncertain. However, in
order for the award to be consistent with governing law and regulation,
the grievant must have met at the time of the disputed promotion the
minimum qualification requirements for the position. Consequently, in
these circumstances, the Authority must take action with respect to the
award to assure that it is consistent with civil service law and
regulation. Accordingly, pursuant to section 2425.4 of the Authority's
Rules and Regulations, the award is modified to provide as follows:
The Grievant shall be awarded a retroactive temporary promotion
for the period June 8, 1983 to August 24, 1983, with backpay in
the amount of the difference between that which she received as a
Library Aid, GS-3, and that which she should have received as a
Library Technician, GS-5, provided the Grievant met on June 8,
1983, the minimum qualification requirements for promotion to the
position of Library Technician, GS-5.
Issued, Washington, D.C., June 19, 1985
Henry B. Frazier III, Acting
Chairman
William J. McGinnis, Jr., Member
FEDERAL LABOR RELATIONS AUTHORITY