Please note that Friday, January 20, 2017, is a federal holiday for the Washington, D.C. metropolitan area.  The following FLRA offices will not be open to accept in-person case filings or to respond to phone calls on that day:  the Authority’s Case Intake and Publication Office, the Office of Administrative Law Judges, the Washington Regional Office, OGC Headquarters (Appeals), and the Federal Service Impasses Panel.  The FLRA’s eFiling System remains available.         

30:0344(42)AR - NAGE Local R4-2 and Navy, Supervisor of Shipbuilding, Conversion and Repair, Newport News, Virginia -- 1987 FLRAdec AR

[ v30 p344 ]
The decision of the Authority follows:

30 FLRA NO. 42
30 FLRA 344

30 NOV 1987






Case No. 0-AR-1384


     I. Statement of the Case

     This matter is before the Authority on exceptions to the
award of Arbitrator Leroy S. Merrifield, filed by the Union under
section 7122 (a) of the Federal Service Labor - Management
Relations Statute (the Statute) and part 2425 of the Authority's
Rules and Regulations. For the reasons discussed below, we deny
the exceptions.

     II. Background and Arbitrator's Award

     The issue before the Arbitrator was whether the Activity
violated the parties' collective bargaining agreement by having a
representative of the Civilian Personnel Office present with the
grievant's immediate supervisor at a meeting at the first step of
a grievance. The Union contended that under the parties'
negotiated grievance procedures the only persons who are
permitted to be present at first-step meetings are the immediate
supervisor, the employee and the employee's Union representative.
The union maintained that the supervisor's insistence that the
personnel specialist be present at the meeting in question was
violative of the agreement. The Union also argued that until the
Activity's violation of the agreement, the prevailing practice
was that the only management representative present at first-step
proceedings was the immediate supervisor. The Activity disagreed
with the Union's position. The Arbitrator determined that neither
the parties' agreement nor past practice precluded a supervisor
from having someone  from the personnel office present at a
first-step meeting. The Arbitrator concluded that the Activity
did not violate the parties' agreement and denied the

     III. Discussion

     In its exceptions, the Union contends that the Arbitrator
erred in concluding that the Activity did not violate the
parties' agreement. The Union also argues that an established
past practice limits management's representation at the first
step of the grievance procedure to the immediate supervisor, and
that the Arbitrator erred in ignoring testimony supporting this

     We conclude that the Union has failed to establish that the
Arbitrator's award is deficient on any of the grounds set forth
in section 7122(a) of the Statute. Specifically, the Union has
failed to establish that the award is contrary to any law, rule
or regulation; or that the award is deficient on any other ground
similar to those applied by the Federal courts in private sector
labor relations cases. See, for example, Oklahoma Air Logistics
Center, Tinker Air Force Base, Oklahoma and American Federation
of Government Employees, Local 916, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, 30 
FLRA  No. 5 (1987) (exceptions which constitute nothing more than
disagreement with an arbitrator's interpretation of a collective
bargaining agreement and reasoning and conclusions and an attempt
to relitigate the merits of a grievance before the Authority
provide no basis for finding an award deficient); Veterans
Administration Medical Center, Kansas city, Missouri, and
American Federation of Government Employees, Local 2663, 29 FLRA 
No. 64 (1987) (exceptions disagreeing with an arbitrator's
evaluation of the evidence and testimony, especially the
credibility of witnesses and the weight to be given to their
testimony, provide no basis for finding an award deficient).

     The Union's exceptions are denied.

     Issued Washington, D.C.,November 30,  1987

     Jerry L. Calhoun, Chairman

     Jean McKee, Member